The Trap (2007) - Notes

This post contains notes about another post - CDS Journal: The Trap (2007)

The Connection Between Conditional Love and the Cold War


This documentary explains that during the cold war in the 1950’s, Friedrich Hayek maintained that societal altruism was destined to fail, and that unregulated individual self-interest was a better solution. The documentary explains how his idea began to prove true with scientific studies into the 1960’s and 1970's.


In order to explain, the documentary spends time showing how things unfolded… which involves understanding what the concept of Game Theory is, how it came about, and how in the early 1960’s a psychiatrist named R.D. Laing used it to study private family life.


Here is a rough transcript of the section of the documentary that talks specifically about the family study and the results. If you want to jump to the section of the video that these words are transcribed from, click HERE (Part 1, 24m 12s) :


In institutions, Laing had noticed that psychiatrists hardly ever spoke to schizophrenics. So, as an experiment, he took twelve women and spent months talking to them about themselves and their lives. The results were dramatic. After just a few months, all twelve were well enough to leave the hospital. However, within a year, Laing discovered that all of them had returned to the hospital. His attempt at a cure had failed completely.


“After this experiment, these women left the hospital, and within a year they were all back again. No one knew why they’d come to the hospital in the first place, and no one knew why they had to come back again. So that shifted my focus to their environment outside the hospital.” - Laing


Laing began to investigate the families of the schizophrenics. His research led him to a hidden closed world where he studied how the members of the families behaved towards each other in private.


Laing’s research into the causes of schizophrenia had convinced him that a much wider range of human problems were caused by the pressure cooker of family life. Laing decided to investigate how power and control were exercised within the world of normal families. To do this, he used the techniques of Game Theory. Laing took twenty couples and, using a complex series of questionnaires, analyzed how each of them saw the other moment-by-moment in their daily life, continually asking them what they secretly thought the other really intended.


The results showed that couples used their everyday actions as strategies to control and manipulate each other. What were normally seen as acts of kindness and love were, in reality, weapons used selfishly to exert power and control. Laing felt that the family was an arena for strategising. Love was a way in which one person tried to dominate another person… aka. “I love you, but I’m making a condition for that love which is impossible for you to fulfil… and so there is nothing you can do to earn my love, even though I’m telling you that you have to earn my love.”


From this research, Laing argued that the modern family was far from being a caring, nurturing institution… and was, in reality, a dark arena where people played continuous selfish games with each other. Out of this struggle came stability in society, but a bleak and limited existence for all the individuals involved.


That last sentence is important. It explains the proliferation of non-altruistic "conditional" love in society. If you watch the documentary from the beginning, it explains how this same power struggle situation was a conscious strategy to encourage a stable society… a concept borrowed from the cold war era. The strategy America used in the war to create a “balance of power” was to build enough destructive force and the intent to use it in order to convince the enemy that both sides would be completely destroyed in a conflict… a strategy which relies on the premise that the enemy wants to survive (not just to win).


Part 2, 53min mark, “The Observer has an effect” - At some point in the last decade, I began to look at scientific studies a bit differently. This was primarily due to my exposure to the “double-slit experiment” from the world of quantum science, which introduced me to the concept of “the observer” as a critical part of the nature of reality. This experiment proved that when matter is observed, it changes state. This specific explanation of it only seemed to apply to quantum physics, which exists only at the extremely small atomic scale world… but it’s actually quite easy to prove that such an idea exists in everyday life as well. For example, if you use a thermometer to measure the temperature of water in a container, you are altering the water temperature in the process because in order for the thermometer to work, some amount of heat must transfer between the water and the thermometer. Therefore, the measurement is not absolutely accurate unless you also understand how much effect the transfer has on the measurement. Earlier in Part 2, the documentary described a scientific study done on a remote tribal community which made a conclusion from the study that seemed clear and reasonable. However, later on… at the 53min mark, there is new information that suggests that the results would be affected by those who did the study by nature of their presence in the environment… something that I have come to believe is a fundamentally misunderstood fact in scientific circles. Ironically, when the documentarians posed this question to the founder of the study, he didn’t respond in a purely scientific way… he defended his original findings and got upset when pressed further on it. This single event would seem to prove that the truth that the documentary is uncovering about society also extends into the scientific world (and why wouldn’t it?).



Comments